17 ways sheep farmers can work towards net zero

Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from sheep production vary greatly depending on farm type and system.

Lower emissions are often associated with lowland systems – largely because more kilos of meat are produced from each hectare or breeding ewe.

Changes to diets, animal management and husbandry, as well as improvements in genetics, all have potential to reduce GHGs. But which have the greatest potential, and how do their costs compare?

See also: 20 ways dairy producers can tackle net zero

Research into a range of mitigation strategies was carried out by a group of scientists for the Centre of Innovation and Excellence in Livestock (Ciel), headed by Professor Elizabeth Magowan from the Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute (see table below).

The research shows, for example, finishing lambs at a younger age would be a low-cost way of cutting both methane and nitrous oxide emissions.

By contrast, feeding a higher starch content diet could be more costly, and more difficult to implement, but could have a significant impact on carbon footprint by reducing methane emissions.

Mitigation strategies to reduce GHG emissions in sheep

Strategy

Cost

Ease of implementation

State of readiness to implement

Potential GHG mitigating effect

Impact on carbon footprint

Other impacts

Accounted for in the National Inventory

Feed

 

Higher starch content diet

Medium

Medium

Now

Methane reductions

Medium

 

Yes

Increasing dietary oil and fat content, dietary inclusion of oilseeds 

Medium

Medium

Now

Methane reductions

Medium

 

Yes

Low crude protein diets

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Medium

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Feeding tannin- and saponin-rich forage

Medium

Medium

Now

Methane reductions

Medium

 

No

Feeding methane inhibitors

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

3-NOP

Unknown

Medium

Later

Methane reductions

High

 

No

Nitrate*

Low

Medium

Later

Methane reductions

Medium

 

No

Active compounds from seaweeds

Unknown

Medium

Later

Methane reductions

High

 

No

Specialised feed ingredients/additives

Low

Medium

Now

Methane reductions

Low

 

No

Forage

 

Grass-legume mixtures, multi-species swards

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Medium

Good for biodiversity

Yes

Improved forage quality by early harvest, increasing grazing frequency, decreasing regrowth interval etc

Low

High

Now

Methane reductions

Medium

 

Yes

Animal

 

Genetic selection for inherently low enteric methane emissions

Low

Low

Later

Methane reductions

Low

 

Yes

Genetic improvement in female productivity (fertility, lower mature weight, health, longevity and early lamb growth/survival)

Low

Low

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Low

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Genetic improvement in terminal productivity traits (e.g., growth rate)

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Low

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Improved animal health

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Medium

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Finish lambs at a younger age

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Medium

Ammonia reductions

Yes

First mating of ewes as lambs rather than yearlings

Low

Medium

Now

Methane and nitrous oxide reductions

Medium

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Manure/fertiliser

 

Nitrification and urease inhibitors

Medium

High

Now

Nitrous oxide reductions

High

Ammonia reductions

Yes

Source: Ciel.

Notes: *Extreme care required during incorporation to diets due to animal health concerns. Impact on carbon footprint was assessed via a carbon calculator.

The National Inventory and inventory accounting is used by the government to measure the carbon emissions and carbon capture at a sectoral and national level.

Low ease of implementation means more difficult to implement. May require infrastructure or full system changes.

Expert view – Liz Genever

Independent beef and sheep consultant Liz Genever says there is a balance to be found between reducing emissions and maintaining productivity on sheep farms.

Below, she offers some practical tips on tackling net zero in lamb production.

Feed and forage

The challenge with strategies such as higher starch diets, increasing dietary oil and fat content and feeding methane inhibitors is that it involves some kind of confinement and buying in feed.

This conflicts with most of the advice for sheep farmers which is to try and maximise production from grass and forage.

This is largely to reduce the risks associated with buying in feed, such as price volatility.

However, in systems that rely on creep feeding, there is potential to make some tweaks to what is being fed.

Generally, barley and wheat and their associated co-products will supply high starch.

Feeding a low crude protein diet is quite difficult to do when a lot of production is reliant on grass and forage – which is inherently higher in protein levels.

A lot of feeding adjustments will be very much system-dependent.

Forage and grassland are a bigger area for intervention.

Rotational grazing on diverse swards has been shown to improve animal performance, which in turn reduces the methane associated with production.

To get the most from multispecies swards: ensure careful management of sward quality; increase the amount of clover to reduce reliance on nitrogen fertiliser; and incorporate herbs to build resilience into the sward under potential stress periods, such as changeable weather.

Genetics

As lovely as it would be to select low-emitting sheep, the relevant data is not yet available in the UK.

However, there has been a huge improvement in how terminal sire traits are recorded. Our challenge now is to get these genetics taken up by the commercial sector and the benefit seen on-farm.

The AHDB RamCompare project shows the benefits of performance-recording animals, in terms of growth rates, but it also shows how big the variation can be.

Genetics is one part of the solution, but it is also important to consider what kind of environment these genetics are being reared on.

Female efficiency should be a big focus for the industry now.

There are some examples of breeds that are doing this, such as Lleyns, which are Signet-recording the highest number of females of any breed in the UK.

This means there is more selection pressure on the females, and it is easier to find the ones that are doing the job and – just as importantly – the ones that are not.

Animal management

Achieving optimum growth rates will aid emissions reductions. Body condition scoring regularly is a way of keeping on top of this.

Mating as ewe lambs may be applicable under some systems, but if done badly, it can go very wrong.

Look at it on a year-by-year basis, assessing what grass cover is available and whether lambs are likely to hit good growth and weight targets, for example.

It is important to prioritise the lamb’s long-term fertility.

Lamb sector snapshot

The report by the Centre for Innovation Excellence in Livestock’s (Ciel), Net zero and livestock: How farmers can reduce emissions, provides a snapshot of the lamb sector:

  • UK lamb and mutton production was valued at £1.3bn in 2020 – accounting for 5% of the UK’s gross agricultural output
  • There are lower emissions in lowland systems than in upland systems in the UK. This is due to higher output (kilo of meat produced) a hectare of land used and/or a breeding ewe in lowland systems
  • In a scientific study, the average GHG emissions intensity of lamb produced by lowland systems measured 11kg carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e)/kg of liveweight and by upland and hill systems 13-18kg CO2e/kg of liveweight

This series takes as its starting point the Centre for Innovation Excellence in Livestock’s recent report, Net zero and livestock: How farmers can reduce emissions

Explore more / Transition

This article forms part of Farmers Weekly’s Transition series, which looks at how farmers can make their businesses more financially and environmentally sustainable.

During the series we follow our group of 16 Transition Farmers through the challenges and opportunities as they seek to improve their farm businesses.

Transition is an independent editorial initiative supported by our UK-wide network of partners, who have made it possible to bring you this series.

Visit the Transition content hub to find out more.